Ranking Taylor Swift’s “From the Vault” Songs: A Comprehensive List

Taylor Swift’s re-recording of her first six albums has been a highly anticipated event for fans, who have been eager to hear their favorite songs in a new light. In addition to re-releasing the tracks off the albums, Swift has also included “From the Vault” songs, featuring collaborations with artists like Keith Urban, Chris Stapleton, and Phoebe Bridgers.

With four albums re-released so far, including “Fearless,” “Red,” “Speak Now,” and “1989,” there are 26 “From the Vault” songs between them. These songs offer a new window into who Swift was at the time she was working on them, exploring themes of love, longing, regret, and revenge.

To determine the best “From the Vault” song, TIME decided to rank them all, excluding the 10-minute version of “All Too Well.” The top spot went to “Nothing New,” featuring Phoebe Bridgers, a haunting track that delves into the idea of losing novelty and reinventing oneself in a culture obsessed with youth.

Other standout tracks include “Mr. Perfectly Fine,” a fearless takedown of a past relationship, and “I Can See You,” a song about forbidden love that captures the electrifying and scary feelings of such a relationship.

Overall, Swift’s “From the Vault” songs have provided fans with a deeper look into her songwriting skills and emotional depth, making the re-recording project a success in reclaiming her original music.